Audio2DJ Monitor Problem

Hey yall, I recently purchased an audio2dj to work with Traktor Pro.

I set up the proper drivers and connected everything properly. I have my master connected to the Left A channel and my headphones connected to the right B channel. My audio setup in traktor is as follows:

Output Monitor

L - 3: Out 3: Audio 2 DJ (CH B left)
R - 4: Out 4: Audio 2 DJ (CH B right)

Output Monitor

L - 1: Out 1: Audio 2 DJ (CH A left)
R - 2: Out 2: Audio 2 DJ (CH A right)

Output Record

- none -
- none -

Now, the problem is that pressing the headphone monitor button on Traktor does not allow me to hear one track in my headphones while another plays through my speakers. Instead, it seems that the master out is being routed to both my speakers and my headphones at the same time. Has anyone encountered this before?