This is from 2015, but still...Originally Posted by astromech
https://djtechtools.com/2015/11/16/k...-2015-edition/
Mixed In Key 7 (and 6)
Mixed In Key’s algorithm remaining the reigning champion in this domain, but did the new update to the software from 6 to 7 make a difference? In our testing, the results were identical – meaning that if an upgrade is only really important if you’re looking for auto-cue points, better energy levels, etc – in terms of the results in key detection, there was no difference. Either way MiK landed the top slot yet again!
Major/Minor Triad Test: 75% – six incorrect.
# of correct tracks (vs human volunteer consensus): 57 (86% correct)
# of Major / Minor misreads: 2
Keyfinder 1.26
Keyfinder is the only free piece of software on this list – and likely the best hope for beating Mixed In Key someday. While the 2.0 version of the software was taken down due to crashing issues, 1.26 still does pretty well in this contest. We’re waiting on a copy of 2.0 in the next week and we will do a followup article to see how it fares.
Major/Minor Triad Test: 33% – 13 incorrect.
# of correct tracks (vs human volunteer consensus): 43 (65% correct)
# of Major / Minor misreads: 5
65% vs. 83%.
Bookmarks