Printable View
Just wondering what everyone's opinion is on the best controller out. It doesn't matter whether it's 2 deck or 4 deck traktor or serato. Id like to see people even go as far for instance to include standalone mixers like a Z2 that doesn't require tt's
I'd say:
-ddj-sx and vci400 for serato
-ableton push for live
-traktor s4 + f1 + x1 for traktor
-EKS otus RAWs + mixer for other software
Kinda comes down to:
- matter of preference (mixing style)
- budget
- the software you want to control (debatable)
- what you can fit (size/weight)
Check this:
All-in-One Controller Guide 2013.
haha by all means if you can direct me to where this thread is already started then help a brother outQuote:
Originally Posted by Audeo
There's no such thing. It's like saying whats the best car ever made? It all depends on the situation. Sure, for a rockstar a Rolls Royce is an amazing tool, but if you're a farmer, you're going to need a Land Rover since the Rolls Royce won't do too well on your farm land.
Pick the tool you need for the job. I have my member firmly jammed in Traktor's ass hole (Although sometimes it feels like the other way around) and after picking up an F1, the S4 was, to me a logical progression, and after three weeks of use it is indeed an absolutely phenomenal controller. For me.
I like the S2 for sound quality, size portability, available mappings and the fact I use traktor.
Wouldn't swap it for any other controller on the market... maybe a VCI 400 EGE but even then that feels a bit cluttered to me.
But preferably i like to use X1, Audio 10, external mixer and, but not essential, TTs... So maybe the X1 is my favorite controller :)
Livid CNTRL:R. Probably the best quality peace out there.
X1
yepQuote:
Originally Posted by photojojo
Quote:
Originally Posted by photojojo
uh huhQuote:
Originally Posted by Jester
Nope you're all wrong :)
NS7 mk2
game over lolz
^what he said
Personally I would love to be able to have a External Mixer and Two X1s
Had this setup except only one X1, it was great until i moved to timecode.Quote:
Originally Posted by 0Notice
2 casette players and a 2 channel mixer
BOSS
As predictable as this response is, most review sites agree with me :)
http://1.bp.blogspot.com/-WNIFd8koH1...3+Remix+05.png
Does that thing really have encoders for the FX section?
For me it's the Denon DN-MC6000, Though that Pio DDJ-SX is looking pretty good...
Standalone?? I never owned one, but the MC6000 has been around long enough for me to call it fairly well built, def think it's gotta be one of the best built standalone controllers.
Modular? I mean I really like my X1. Not much to it to go wrong, but at the same time I've never had a problem w/ it, and I dont recall seeing anyone writing about any malfunctions.
Yeah, they work well though. They're depress-capable encoders as well, so you can map them so pressing them resets the effect parameters; VERY useful for Macro FX as they'll reset instantly to the 50% mark (off).Quote:
Originally Posted by makar1
Tactile feedback from pots is much better IMO, you can reset them almost as easily, and are smooth apart from the detent. I read from one of the comments that the Jockey FX encoders have clicks? I guess that's why they added Dry/Wet functionality to the channel faders..
Also why did they put on a Cue/Master mix mini fader in the middle? A standard pot would be so much better.
What a silly question.
Also how has nobody said BCR-2000?
I'd also make a claim that the Xone K2 is up there.
Midi fighter 3D deserves a spot as well.
Also, LMAO @ the couple silly kids that actually typed "S2" or "S4" as a serious response for the best controller on the market.
Actually, fuck it, as long as we're only talking about DJ controllers, technically speaking the CDJ-2000 nexus is the best controller ever made.
For EQing, definitely. Not so much for effects though; the fact that there are now TWO different types of effects (Normal and Macro) in Traktor confused the issue; you want pots with center detents for the Macro ones (and HARD detents, because even 1/100th either side and the sound changes drastically), and ones without for normal effects; encoders is a good alternative when neither type of pot is really ideal for every situation. But they have to be push encoders for that reset capability, otherwise they're a nightmare to use.Quote:
Originally Posted by makar1
As for the fader, no idea tbh. Probably a design choice for some sort of "symmetry" between the two channel faders and the crossfader. I'd have used a knob, personally. I suppose it's better visual feedback though.
Ps3 controller for size and portability
And the fact that you can have it update parameters as you scroll through regular fx is priceless IMO, no need to play catch up. non click encoders for the job or endless pots with led/screen feedback.Quote:
Originally Posted by mdcdesign
There's a big difference between the two. I'd say the S4 is still a contender.Quote:
Originally Posted by octostout
Considering NHL & MIDI modes, Timecode support, and all of the same controls the X1 the piece the DJTT vets voted for. I've got mine spinnin' like a top.
Both of those "features" are just NI locking out the competition through software so they can actually get people to buy their average controllersQuote:
Originally Posted by DJ Abide
The buttons on the X1 are much nicer than any of those on the S4Quote:
Originally Posted by DJ Abide
Edit:
How is this any different from standard Filters? How many filters have you seen that use encoders?Quote:
Originally Posted by mdcdesign
Quote:
Originally Posted by makar1
Exactly.
To everything he just said.
S4 is not even close to a contender. It has among the wost build-quality of any controller most of us have ever seen, and it's ONLY strengths come from NI locking down features to give them exclusively to their own.... A failure which actually makes the controller WORSE than others, because it means you can't effectively remap it.
Yes for me the MC6000 would be my top "all in one" however the traktor version of the DDJ-SX would be badass.Quote:
Originally Posted by jakeintox
We have neither price nor ETA... :(Quote:
Originally Posted by Hippie
Are jog wheels a must for you? And what's your price range. If you can afford it, it's advisable to go get a pair of cdj's that have midi mapping features. My choice would be the Denon DNS3700 or 3900s, these cdjs have a real direct drive platter to control cds, usb sticks, or they can be put into "hybrid midi mode" and send midi over usb and timecode signals through audio at the same time. And a legit mixer that does midi as well. If you are anything like me, the more you use a program like Traktor, the more you long to ditch the laptop from time to time. It's nice to know that if you are playing live and your laptop goes down, you have a legit pair of decks and a mixer. But that will be pricy.
I have a Stanton SCS.1m and 1.d. Legit direct drive turntable with a real piece of vinyl to control Traktor. And one deck controls 4 in Traktor. It's pretty awesome, but there is a very small community around it.
If you want to get really geeky, an Electrix Tweaker is a good idea. It comes with a Traktor mapping as well as an Ableton Live mapping. Plus (and this is my favorite part) an editor software to build your own mappings and behaviors for buttons, knobs and faders. Also 8 velocity sensitive pads. It's a little pricy for a controller that has no audio interface, but all in all its a pretty open canvas of a controller. Honestly, I just got mine, and I'm overwhelmed with all the possibilities.