Maschine and Traktor are not the least bit redundant. They only are if you're not using Maschine for live production work.
What you want to do is definitely possible, but I have no idea how to do it on Windows. You need something to get the midi clock between them and possibly something to get the audio between them…but if all you want to do is play beats along with your Traktor set, you can just give Maschine it's own sound card and run it to an input on the S4…assign it to a deck, and pick "Live Input" as the deck type. I've done that, and it works very well, though if you're using real sound cards (as opposed to virtual sound cards like Soundflower or Jack) then the latency gets to be an issue very quickly if you're planning on playing anything live.
As far as playing live goes…I don't see the point. If all you want is drum pads attached to samples, sync'd to a midi clock…I'd probably get an MPC over Maschine. But I like simple. And just triggering samples is far to simple to be worth the hassle, even for me.
On Windows and especially with the S4, I'd go ahead and give up on any aspirations of sampling into Maschine in real time or using Maschine's effects on your Traktor audio…it's a hack at best and kind of requires other software, since Traktor can't use volume controls while in external mixing mode, and Maschine can't take input from other controllers (other than a basic keyboard).
I figured out how to do it using Ableton as well…but I wouldn't trust it at all in a live situation.
If you used a real mixer, it'd be a lot easier. It's just one more reason that I think these all-in-one DJ consoles are a fad. They're not adaptable enough.
Now, I have done it with all controllers just routing Maschine's audio into Traktor to use as an extra deck, and it was brilliant. You could do that fairly easily. Well…you can on a Mac. I assume it's possible on a PC, but I have no idea the specifics of how to do it.
I'm going to run an experiment some time this week of running Traktor's audio into Maschine and using Maschine as both a groove box and a mixer. It'll be weird, but I'm convinced it'll work. It might even be a lot of fun, though I can't see it appealing to too many people.
Bookmarks