"Music Theory for Computer Musicians" vs "Dance Music Manual"

[xyloft]

I just stumbled upon this discussion and have become very interested in getting either of the books. I have just began to really put time into producing after about 5 years of Djing and having FL studios for a solid 2 years. I have no background with playing instruments and was wondering which one would be best for me to read?

i've only read the one, but i think the computer musiciain book is pretty comprehensive. Although it does have a chapter on musical notation, it does not really require you understand that to move forward.

[Xonetacular]

Hmmm I might have to get both

[muffintop]

Both are great. The dance music manual is more geared towards specific music styles. The music theory for computer musicians is more ''basic'' theory. I have both, but having a background in music I find myself using the Dance Music Manual more often

Both are extremely useful though

[Xonetacular]

I just ordered the second edition which got good reviews and is aparrently on par with the first or better

[ame="http://www.amazon.com/Dance-Music-Manual-Second-techniques/dp/0240521072/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1322893998&sr=8-1"]Amazon.com: Dance Music Manual, Second Edition: Tools. toys and techniques (9780240521077): Rick Snoman: Books@@AMEPARAM@@http://ecx.images-amazon.com/images/I/619gMSnq1tL.@@AMEPARAM@@619gMSnq1tL[/ame]

I still don't really understand music theory so i'm considering music theory for computer musicians but the reviews are mixed- apparently there are some mistakes that are confusing for beginners and one review said they were expecting a lot more piano roll

[damiengoundrie]

I've been teaching Electronic Music Production for 7 years and my suggestion is that you read both books.