I’d do it… I’d sell just one if it were me though. I’d like to still have the resources and gear to allow manual BMing. Keep the single X1 and have it on right of mixer with the maschine and the other CDJ on the left… Look at that… I want it NAO! lol
You can have any interface layout that you want with a touchable surface. You can build your own interface and change it whenever you want.
If you need tactile feel to some of the controls, you can buy a midi controller for this specifique control (Examples: midifighter, dicer, etc)
If you don’t want to adjust the EQ and the Volume using the touch screen you can use an external audio interface with 2 or 4 (2 decks or 4 decks) stereo outs and use the club’s mixer with all the oldschool tactile feel and with less preconception from the CDJ+ANALOG MIXER purists…
This will be my route, I don’t know if it fits you, but the thread is for suggestions, right?