Whiich is better? Mixed in Key or Traktor Key detection

[Morior]

Hi All

Im trying to get a concensus here on which of the two is better. Quite often the Mixed in Key analysis does not match the Traktor Analysis. Ive tried to figure it out for myself but I find that if I decide to use Mixed in Key I get the occasional bad match, but if I switch to the Traktor Key detection I can get some to match that Mixed in Key gets wrong but then others dont match!! Its pretty maddening, Im tending to fall on the side of Mixed in Key though but it would be great to see what others think.

Mo

[SlayForMoney]

KeyFinder ftw

[Rip van Winkle]

mixed in key is better than traktor according to some tests i found. keyfinder is a very good free alternative

[Morior]

Yeah theres always alternatives but I aint going that road. So its a toss up between Mixed in Key and the Native one, its just every time I settle on one, i start to doubt it (I'm talking here about maybe 1 in 7 tracks that may not seem to be correct.)

[c0nsul]

tested a lot of different key finding software. And each of them isn´t perfect!! keyfinder, MIK and rekordbox give sometimes different keys for the same tracks. Even when I have duplicates of tracks the softwares are saying that they have different keys... I know it´s frustrating. So I´m stuck on only one key finding tool otherwise it would make me made. I use rekordbox and change the found keys into open keys and write it into the comments. Can´t say anything about traktor´s key finding because I´m still using TP1.2.7.

My tip would be, stay with traktor´s key finding feature. NI will continue to improve that feature and they have the approach to do it as perfectly as possible. And this way round you won´t need extra programms.

[Jester]

KeyFinder ftw

yep. way beter than either

http://www.ibrahimshaath.co.uk/keyfinder/

[Morior]

My tip would be, stay with traktor´s key finding feature. NI will continue to improve that feature and they have the approach to do it as perfectly as possible. And this way round you won´t need extra programms.

That's a good point and will probably sway me towards using it exclusively. I know lots of people mention Keyfinder but I want to try and reduce my software footprint.

Cheers
Mo

[SomeoneWhoIsntMe]

Keyfinder is a pretty lightweight app, and it's free... you also only need to tag your mp3's every time you buy a cart of songs so having an extra app to analyse tracks isn't a huge deal IMHO.

As for the accuracy, even if it's not 100%, it's just a tool to help plan out track selection a little better. Do you not drop the needle in the middle of the incoming track and preview it before you decide to mix it in?