I can vouch for all these brands, although I have not used monitors from mackie, only bigger speakers.
In my experience, the KRKs are more pleasing to listen on, but not as flat as the HS series. The KRKs feel nicer for listening and DJing on, partly because I’m not using a sub and they have a bit of bass. For producing, the HS would be better I’d say. not sureif thats your interest.
personally, for djing/listening i like the krks better than anything i heard in that price range. i also got my 8’s for $170 each and my 5’s were free (both brand new from guitar center btw) so it’s hard to pass them up at those prices.but yes, it’s subjective so go and listen to all of them if you can and choose from there.as far as the controllers, you have to ask yourself what will be best for you flow.*the f1 has knobs/faders and works tightly with traktors remix decks right out of the box.*mdf spectra/3d have no knobs but awesome arcade buttons for doing multiple quick hits if you’re into that.*the launchpad has a ton of buttons which you can map the remix decks and effects without having to change banks, but the buttons are smaller.
This topic comes up SO frequently, we need a sticky.
Usually these threads end with a few people explaining that monitors are great for production, but not well-suited to DJing. You’re much better off with some hi-fi speakers and an amplifier. Better sound quality, and it’s also much, much cheaper.
I was buying a maschine mk1 and they matched a pro audio star package deal for free 5s. Even better, a week later ni put maschine on sale and gc gave me the extra money back to reflect the new price. Good timing and the best deal I’ve gotten from them.