It’s all preference. Mine goes as follows:
Pro Tools >> Logic >> Ableton Live >> Everything else.
I prefer working in PT because of some of the workflow/UI features, though Logic is very close. Logic winds up the most cost effective if you’re already on Apple and don’t want to record any hardware, since Logic Pro is now like $200 and you don’t really need an audio interface just for output, certainly not to start.
Pro Tools comes in pretty close, since the cost of an MBox Mini + Pro Tools 9 is like $600 or so, which sound steep…until you realize that it’s actually a pretty good interface for the money, the stuff it comes with rivals Ableton Studio (which costs more without an interface) and in some ways beats Logic Pro, and the software actually costs $600 on its own, so the interface is basically free.
The only caveat about Pro Tools is that Avid’s a bit weird about support. If your computer isn’t avid certified (the information is on their website), there’s no guarantee it’ll work at all. And you have to be really careful about OS updates to make sure you don’t break anything. And I’m not sure which versions do or do not come with an iLok, but you need one (they’re like $50 on their own).
Agreed. You can switch later, but focusing on one first will seriously help.
The only difference between my advice and everyone else’s is that it’s hard to find demos for them and it’s even harder to make a legit comparison between them if you don’t already have a clue what you’re doing. So, go find as many tutorial videos as you can and base your decision on how much sense they make to you.
Yes, that means you’re going to be judging things almost as much on the quality of the tutorial videos as on your impression of the software, but that’s not horrible for a first DAW, since you’re going to be lost for a while.
I used Ableton as my first serious DAW and thought it was incredible. About the time I wrapped my head around it, I decided I wanted to shop around and tried all the major contenders. And Pro Tools won.