i know that this is probably a long-time issue with Traktor and is a constant discussion with heads at the nI Forums, but i’m just curious to know if anyone here’s managed to solve that problem? or rather, in process of?
tried various ways to troubleshoot but i’m somehow still unsatisfied with what i get. and this happens when i run 4Ds with effects switched on on 2Ds/more.
best part is that this crackle thing doesn’t happen on Ableton and Reason and iTunes and whatever medium which plays audio/video. and it can’t possibly be that i’m running 3 bus-powered controllers at the same time?
tried/tested:
i switched off Keylocks
i even switched off Airport
i closed all other programs too
it’s not the tracks that i have (most are 320kbps)
it’s definitely not firewire cable/adapter jack problems
it’s definitely not ext soundcard hardware issues
latency has been set to the minimum (some people think that setting it higher will probably solve the issue?)
i’ll be glad to have good insights from you ladies and gentlemen
here’s my rig for references if any:
Macbook | 2GB 667MHz DDR2 SDRAM | 2.2GHz Intel Core 2 Duo | OSX 10.5.8 | Presonus Firebox | Traktor Pro 1.2.1 | M-Audio X-Session Pro | Novation Remote SL Zero | Korg MicroKontrol |
Crackles and pops are nearly always related to a latency issue, so I would revisit that. Also check those cables again (I know you said you did, but you can never be too sure). I run a system with specs much like yours, and never have problems unless latency isn’t dialed in. Various things can affect this though. I’d start by making sure you are using the very latest firmware and drivers for your interface. Turn any networking or wireless processes off. Try if possible to run your devices on a powered usb hub, if you have more devices than ports. It’s very unlikely that midi would be affecting crackle and pop behavior though. Try setting your latency at various places between 2.5 and 13ms, with your sampling rate at 44.1k, for basic troubleshooting. If you find a good spot, you can mess with increasing or decreasing the values accordingly. Sometimes you may need to exit the program and unpower/repower the interface to get the new settings to “stick”. I have had that very problem before, crackles even though I changed my settings, but a simple on/off of the app and interface clears it up.
You may want some extra RAM, but your 2GB should be fine. FYI, I run my system at 24bit, 44.1k, 2.5ms, 2 controllers, TPro + Ableton + Translators, mp3, WAV, whatever, without any glitches ever.
thanks for the insight man. i’ve tried restarting devices and softwares on and off quite awhile back though it didn’t seem to work. latency-wise, i actually run at the lowest but i’d probably tweak more here and there. sampling rate’s definitely a 44.1.
i’ve even tried to cut down on dual-software usage (traktor & ableton) but to no avail.
i might go get a new firewire cable, though these crackles haven’t affected any other software (and ableton uses heaps of cpu).
for now i actually run traktor with the efx switches off and switching on between the decks. quite a hassle till i find out the problem area (or just use ableton completely heh)before any incoming show. soon hopefully.
Shit brother, I forgot to mention that if none of these things solves your issue, that I’m super-bummed for you, 'cause I wouldn’t know what else to troubleshoot in the mac world. Maybe also try disabling the dashboard? There’s an app for that at apple.com. There’s nothing worse than a problem you just can’t isolate. What version of Traktor are you running?
You should be able to run Traktor with all 4 decks and FX with Keylock on with your Mac.
I have a MBP (2007) 2.16 / 3GB and i use the Firebox and i have latency set at 5ms / sample rate 4400 with zero pops and clicks.
It is a total fantasy that you need to get your latency any lower than 5ms. If you can thats great but any lower than 5ms is un-noticable and whilst people will tell you different it is just not true. And NI only advise 10ms anyway.
With 2GB of RAM you will have to up your latency. Try 10ms and then lower it until the pops start then up it until they go again.
haha thanks zac for feeling me on this one. i’m running a 1.2.1 and probably the dashoboard idea’s abit weird but i’ll have my take on the latency and RAM of my machine. probably traktor feeds on graphics and processors at the same time, who knows.
karlos thanks for the eye-opener on the latency thing too. it’ll probably be on the paper edge and i’d have to back the hell up of everything that’s in here but it’ll probably be good in the long run.
it’s weird that T3 didn’t have such issues as far as my mind stretches.
well i definitely can’t sweat the latency and i sure can’t on the technique for that!
Yeah sample rate again, is down to the machine 41 is fine, totally.
If you can raise is without issues then thats cool but a Latency below 10ms and a sample rate of 41000 will sound good.
People get far to wrapped up in this stuff and in my experience they get too nerdy about it.
The reality is your machine has one optimal setting. Find it and use it and then spend your time playing and not fretting about a millisecond here and there.
44.1 is fine. It was chosen as a standard for a reason. Upping the sample rate really benefits you the most when you are recording - you don’t have to drive things as hot, and you get more dynamic range out of the recording.
appears that it’s very much the latency on the settings; though i actually had my rss reader and airport off at the same time while having shit upped to 10ms.
thanks again guys for the insights.
now it’s back to 4Decks, EFX and a 909. emulator. heh.
Get some more memory, it can never hurt and since I upgraded to 4gb I have had way fewer issues. Also, PM me if you want to buy some super cheap laptop DDR2 ram you can pop in and speed things up.
The only thing I still have an issue with is sometimes when I turn FX units on a deck I get a horrible distorted crackling noise, it’s strange. Luckily it seems to only happen during practice messing around (I use fewer effects live) so thankfully it hasn’t screwed up a set. I would like to eliminate it altogether though.
thanks man
more RAM definitely sounds good – but of course before the task of backing up on everything in here.
yeah seems like having 2 or more FX switched on might be the problem as well, which is weird. hopefully it doesn’t affect live shows. if it does during soundcheck, i’d have to revert back to Live lol
