I'm suprised there is so much hate..

I was a vinyl DJ for a decade before I even looked at software. The 2 aren’t mutually exclusive although you would think so to read some of the crap posted on this forum

Well I did say it was a “cliche” but really? Have you never been in the presence of a DJ for 4 or 5 hours who takes the whole club up and down and plays a set that totally gets everyone feeling like they are witnessing something special… No, really?

That’s fine, you are entitled to your view. Kinda the whole point of my original post.
I still say you have missed out on something special. Beggars belief which DJ’s you go to see.

No you don’t. Thats ridiculous. There are plenty of DJ’s that simply stick with what they know and they have huge crowds and are in huge demand. Again with the “my way or the highway” attitude.

Nah. I refute that completely. I maybe from a traditional background and I maybe an “old head” but you can hardly say i am only that.
I have more controllers than most people on this forum. I edit the Traktor Bible. I am a Moderator for the worlds most commercially popular digital dj software. As far as Traktor goes I am at the cutting edge testing all Traktor products. Hardly stuck in the past.

Again, why think in such a polarised way..?

It’s not old farts vs kids. Its close minded people & intolerant people against open minded and tolerant people.

Absolutely - and there are plenty of ALL of 'em on all sides.

This is what the scene looks today. In the past it wasn’t like this. People went to gigs for the music. Even today the underground is still filled with people who want the music, not the booze. The problem is the over-marketing of these fake ass huge parties with “djs” spinning premixed cd’s. That’s what people want NOW.

+1. But in 50 years we’ll have private, virtual-reality, mind-controlled parties right at home…
not looking good for djs

Great post Karlos.

True, but you have to agree that that’s you. I personally know quite a lot of oldskool vinyl djs who still carry 30kg crates of wax to their gigs because “true djs spin vinyl”

True. Definitely. I know some vinyl DJs that think any controller is an abomination. I have friends who cannot for the life of them understand why I do what I do with controllers.

Guys, come on. It’s still like that.
I dunno where you guys go clubbing but this whole (and I have to say it appears American) thing about $1,000 tables and bottles of whatever expensive piss people drink on Jersey Shore (im guessing at that) is alien to me and probably most others.
There are plenty of clubs in UK that are just an oblong room with a DJ at one end and a crowd going mad in front. They go for the music and they know their music.

It’s not a lost cause.

Yup I know quite a few. Some are just stuck in the past but some, they are doing it because that is what they love and some are making a good living.

A lot of people on this forum seem to like Mr Scruff. He is a good example of a DJ that uses vinyl and some CD but has a very traditional approach. He’s killing it and has been for 15 years or more.

obv u point urself out makes my point. DJTT has some pretty open minded moderators/people working for them. I KNOW outliers exist. I KNOW vinyl DJs can have controllers… but you can’t deny that MOST of the time theres a huge divide. every hip hop DJ I know in Philly wont touch a controller… or even CDJs for that matter… and most of the EDM crowd in Philly uses controllers… theres a divide, and im not being narrow minded by saying that… you have to admit it.

I take your point. The older heads on DJTT arent the usual older heads simply by the nature of the forum.

I would add that maybe your perspective is skewed in the US . UK djs are much more forgiving. In fact most of my peers are now digital.

There is a divide. I would never doubt it. My whole point is this divide has no place on a forum that was born in a time when we were very much the minority and should know better than to be intolerant of any form of DJing as long as it is creative.

including mine.

but yes, this +1000.

Hey Patch,

I’m talking about a simple setup. 2 decks, A & B and a mixer.

In my opinion simple volume fades and minor EQ’ing are the essence of dj’ing.. The bare bones. EQ overkill can be a disaster on your ears or just irritating, minor EQ’ing should and simple volume fades should be standard!

I personally think it’s not always about how ‘creative’ one can be when playing a set. If I’m listening to someone deliver incredible track selection with solid mixing, I couldn’t be happier.. Just minor EQ’ing and simple fader control! (In other words cutting the low end so the bass doesn’t clash and bringing tracks in and out with the up-faders)

Let the music do the work!

If you’re like me and learnt to mix records on vinyl, I wouldn’t go as far as to say is was easy, even beat matching on CDJ’s before they had solid BPM counters wouldn’t have been easy without prior experience from vinyl. I think what you’re saying is that anyone can beatmatch with the tools available today.. But that wasn’t really the point of what I was talking about.

Bit of a generalisation stating DJ’s need to WANT to be more creative, some of us don’t, in fact, a lot of us. For us it’s about track selection and solid A > B mixing.

I really wasn’t referencing people who have only been into it for a couple of months.. I think we ALL share the same opinion on folk who jump on Traktor, smash the sync button and call themselves DJ’s, you can only laugh at it.

Just out of curiosity have you played live in a venue, using anything other than decks A&B? (Not Traktor) I’ve heard some people try and use F1’s and Maschines live and in my opinion it sounds pretty bad. Clashing, out of pitch, irrelevant, unmastered and either way to forward in the mix or so subtle that it may aswell not be there.

Just curious Patch, what is your idea of creative skills and tecniques?

LESS IS MORE!

Cheers,

J

I think we ALL know that not to be true:wink:

You sir get 2 votes :stuck_out_tongue:!

The way I see it, that’s the problem. There is so much narrowed minded-segregation, that the community creates, to some how make themselves/oneself more “legit”. Haze324 hit it on the head in another thread when he said “We gotta stop making it about the GEAR”.

Amen.

Worth a watch if you haven’t seen it. I suggest watching the whole thing but Theo Parrish talks about what we’re discussing @03.13

^^Legend. Seen him a few times.

You know what’s good Karlos

Finally, a thread with some common sense in it :wink:

Some excellent points from karlos and others and have to agree that, for me, its ALL about the music. I’m stunned to read someone interested or involved in the club scene that doesn’t believe in the journey idea in a set. Some of the greatest DJ’s of all time were capable of taking a floor on a journey with the simplest of tools, but an encyclopedic knowledge of their music and the crowd. People like David Mancuso or Larry Levan did use reel to reel, but their sets revolved around the correct tune at the right time.

Just to put a little context about myself - i’m 50 years old, been DJ’ing since about '87, still have all my vinyl and still buy vinyl, but also have controllers and CDJ’s. I used to have (in the early 90’s) a large fully digital recording studio, but still prefer analogue instruments :slight_smile:

For me its all about convenience - if I could take all the vinyl I needed each time, I would, but some clubs dont have 1200’s, all have CDJ’s.

Id rather dance to a DJ capable of holding the floor with the tunes he selects rather than killing the vibe with overuse of FX and EQ, hot queues etc. But its not just the new heads that fall into this trap - i’m really not a fan of the DJ’s that use Isolators and play the EQ like an intrument, some are great at it (theo Parrish), but some I cant listen to (Clausell).

As much as I agree with Mr. Parish, that’s a cache 22. The stigma that “you can’t be professional if you use of a controller” or " you have to know how to play on tables/cdj’s" will, and does, perpetuate the growth of technology. Kids and new DJ’s are breaking their backs to get that gear (I know, I tricked myself into it). If discussions were spent more on the individual, creativity, music and based off of constructive criticism, then maybe we would see it more then just as a convenience.

There’s a lot of “wrong” in this thread, so rather than quoting everyone individually I’ll simply say the following.

A lot of you are failing to grasp what being a DJ means in this day and age. Years ago, a DJ was the only reliable method of providing a continuous, unbroken stream of music to an audience for 5-6 hours. Their job was to put one track on after the other, nothing more and nothing less. The craft evolved to include beatmatching to create a more seamless performance, suddenly everyone became “DJs” because this required a small element of talent, as opposed to just human jukeboxes.

A short time after this, the first “performance” DJs appeared - scratch artists. They were pretty smart and realised that simply playing one track after the other wasn’t a sustainable craft, and needed something extra as a hook. And so for years, the industry carried on like this; two camps of DJs, the jukebox-evolved beatmatchers, and the performance-inspired scratchers.

And then, in comes digital music formats; specifically, pre-mixed CDs. Thousands of venues sack their DJs because it’s a hell of a lot cheaper to just buy a couple of CDs than pay for a DJ every night. This continues for a while, and then the DJ companies add “Effects” to their mixers. Crappy, non-beatsynced effects, sure, but effects nonetheless. Some DJs get their jobs back, yay!

Then digital DJing makes an appearance, and the rise of Sync. Suddenly, even a monkey can do what the old jukebox DJs had been doing for years. Instead of learning to evolve, the old DJs start whining about how Sync is “cheating”, and how you’re only a real DJ if you use CDs/Vinyl etc. The scratch artists basically just laugh and say, “well it’s still not as good as vinyl” - and for their purposes, they’re right.

And finally, a new type of DJ appears; specifically a new type of “performance” DJ, who uses software and MIDI controllers the way a scratch DJ uses a slipmat; to create new material the audience hasn’t heard before. Now, correct me if I’m wrong, but this forum was primarily established to cater for the latter?

If you ask me, if you’re doing A–B mixing, you’re part of the old “jukebox DJ” group, and you might as well just quit and let a lightly-trained monkey with VDJ/Traktor’s cruise mode take over from you.