I'm suprised there is so much hate..

Times change, things move on. That doesn’t mean that old means irrelevant.

Stop looking at things in such a linear way. You are failing to grasp that there is more to DJing than just what is new and forward thinking.

So you are telling me that Theo Parrish (as an example) is a “jukebox dj”.

Again you fail to acknowledge the art of selecting music and programming a set. A monkey, no matter how well trained cannot do this, neither can many djs.

Again, a fairly harmless debate, has been ruined by a couple of idiots who cannot see anyone else’s opinion.

Agreed.

I also think folks fail to realize there is a difference between mixing 2 decks and playing ON two decks. I’ve seen some great shows of guys playing on two decks all night and killing it. The limitation in creative options is not always created by the gear you are using, but by the DJ themselves.

Yup, and interestingly its the same offenders each time. I honestly wish these people would travel and listen to other DJ’s more rather than just stick with their own group or genre. Its a crying shame.

i definitely recommend this book.

great read.

It’s all about the music. On the fly fx are all well and good but they don’t really make what’s being played any better as such, just slightly different. Any more and it’s probably going to be too much. Real, good, proper music speaks for itself and it takes an expert to put it together properly. You can mash up your Swedish House Mafia and ‘trap’ all you like, the kids will lap it up.

The point of being a dj is, as it always was, playing music to entertain a crowd. The methods and tools don’t matter, as long as your crowd is entertained.

Yeah i’ve heard stuff about the UK scene.
I live in a small country (2 million people), deep in the mountains. Here booze is a “tradition”, if you want to call it like that, so the recent rise of clubs here has grown together with the idea that going out=drinking till you pass out.

In the capital there are some nice clubs, not so known stuff. But they mostly host dub/jungle artists, so there really aren’t almost any places to spin what i want.
Therefore i’ve accustomed myself to the fact that every gig i do, i will have a minimum of 4 drunk guys with glasses in their hands at a time, dripping red wine&cola over my gear and asking for gangnam style. Now of course i know the scene is a lot different in other countries, but i’m mainly relating to what’s happening where i live :slight_smile:

I don’t get why there can’t be different styles of DJ. It doesn’t have to be this way or another way. You’re supposed to express yourself through whatever means calls to you. If it’s A->B, do it! If it’s FXing and mashing up, do it!

I personally hate it when DJs just overload a track with FX…

I’m in LOVE with your post.

If you want to mix A>B do it. If you want to mix 4 decks do it. If you want to perform all your tracks live do it. It’s just if you start innovating and being creative by using 4 decks, drum machines and whatever else you will get heads turning people will realise that you’re doing more than the guy fading the last 30 seconds of each track on his CDJ’S.

Going back to this journey thing..

I work in the most top40/pophouse/kidsrequestcalvinharris+thriftshop club around in Philly.. and I STILL find a way to mix rap/pop/house/classics in a way that IT IS a journey and its not just one giant ipod shuffle of hits. It def is possible and its the best feeling when people come up to u at the end of the night and tell you that your amazing at being able to mix not only songs, but different genres.

To me it doesnt matter what you use… a DJ should be knowledgeable in music history/theory/specialization and be able to make people dance non stop. just how theres different “musicians” (some people call banging two spoons together an instrument) then there should be different “DJs” (and no being a sucky DJ doesnt count. i mean digital/vinyl/live/selector/whatever)

Thats pushing the hate a little too far IMO. Anyone can make the argument that a DJ’s job, even the button mashers, can be replaced with a machine. There are programs out there that can do the exact same button mashing effects that a lot of the performers can do now. Whats to stop someone from loading a set into Ableton and have that program running, with some fancy lights synced to it?

Just like the few good posters in this thread, I appreciate song selection moreso than any effect masher. However, I think the button mashers are a nice way of refreshing the scene, to an extent. If your set comprises of 4 or five songs over 45 minutes, then theres a problem calling yourself a DJ.

For instance, I saw the interview with Araab Muzic a few months back. While I was impressed with his MPC skills, theres no way I could pay $20 to hear that for an hour. On the other hand, seeing a performer like DJ Shadow, was worth every penny.

The same argument can be said for turntablists. There are quite a few of em out there that can scratch like its no ones business and layer a great set, but theres quite a few that rely only on their scratching skills with rudimentary mixing (i.e. quick slams, baby scratch lead ins and talking on the mic)

A–B mixing is simply what a DJ did 20 years ago and its something that evolved with the addition of music. Our job as DJs are easy, but our goal should be worked for.

not to toot my own horn or anything.. but im a 24 year old DJ with a steady gig in one of the bigger clubs in Philly, and I use a traktor s4 BARELY touching any FX (mainly filter and EQing/selection) skills. I dont like scratching… people dont come to the club to hear my scratching.. or to hear my echo freezes… they come to hear good tunes mixed well with other good tunes… and to think I need to up my game with crazy FX and loud scratching is a bit silly and egotistical.

i just like the s4 cause its so easy for me to travel with. its as simple as that. ive had (gonna get racial here, but Philly is a very racial/diverse city…) black kids come up to me sayin im a sic DJ but question why I dont use vinyl.. and then I have like college EDM kids come up to me saying that traktor is awesome, but why am I wasting my time wit it if Im not using “cool FX” and bumping Knife Party…

i just laugh at both groups of people and keep doing my thing

I just ordered the digital (ah, the irony) version for my Kindle Fire.
Thanks.

Tell that to Digweed :wink:

hahah exactly! all other forms of media are evolving.. why does music have to be kept back! digital progression is the future, as long as we incorporate our roots/history as we evolve.

Lol, you know what I mean. At least I hope you do ;p Saw him in 09 @ Redrocks.

Exactly.
I need to ad that to my growing list of DJ quotes.

So because we have photoshop every photo taken should be airbrushed to shit and have mad filters?

Because we have after effects every film and video should be about insane fx and we forget about storyline?

Why are books even still around… That’s the old way of telling stories!

Etc